Oreo Cookie Cookies
May 15, 2007 at 3:45 pm | In recipe |
a cookie inside a cookie. what could possibly be wrong with that concept?
recipe adapted from cookiemadness
makes 18 medium sized cookies
5 T Earth Balance margarine
5 T granulated sugar
5 T light brown sugar
1 t vanilla
1 Ener-g egg replacer
1 cup AP flour [scooped up & leveled, not spooned]
1/2 t baking soda
pinch sea salt
1/2 t baking powder
1/4 t cream of tartar
5 oreo-style cookies [I use Trader Joe-Joe's], cut in half, then cut in thirds
2 T semisweet chocolate chips
preheat oven to 350F. line a baking sheet with parchment paper.
beat margarine and sugars together until creamy. add “egg”, vanilla, beat until smooth.
in a separate bowl, sift together flour, baking powder, baking soda, cream of tartar, and salt.
add flour mix to margarine mix, combine well.
add oreo pieces and chocolate chips with your hands, being careful not to crush oreo pieces too much.
form into balls, 1 1/2 T worth of dough per cookie. don’t flatten your cookies.
place on baking sheet. bake for 10 minutes, or until the edges are brown.
let cool on sheet for a few minutes before attempting to remove. place on cooling rack.
29 Comments »
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI
Leave a comment
-
flickr
More Photos
Blog at WordPress.com. | Theme: Pool by Borja Fernandez.
Entries and comments feeds.
those look magical! you are a cookie goddess!!!
Comment by nikki — May 15, 2007 #
thank you Nikki! they were fun to make. and easy. like me! er. whatever that means.
Comment by Celine — May 15, 2007 #
those are awesome! mmmm . . .
Comment by appifanie — May 15, 2007 #
best….cookie….EVER!!!! you dont even know how obsessed with oreos i am. and when you put a cookie within a cookie-well thats just plain cool.
Comment by Emily — May 16, 2007 #
it opens the door for so much more craziness. I can’t even take it.
Comment by Celine — May 16, 2007 #
Wow, nikki said it best, cookie goddess!
I’m gonna have to make a double batch of these…Not because I’m going to share, because I’m really going to eat 12 monster cookies! I’m serious!
Yeah, it’s crazy, but it’s genius, too!
Comment by danucal — May 17, 2007 #
be prepared to have people throw themselves at you for you to bake more for them! they’re goooooooooooood. I froze some of mine so that I wouldn’t eat them all in one sitting. sinful to the max! :D
I’m so glad to see your blog hasn’t gone, danucal! I was a bit worried. yay!
Comment by Celine — May 18, 2007 #
I’m actually sort of scared of the riot that will occur when I mention these cookies. Maybe I’ll make two double batches…One to calm me down, the other to enjoy after the cookie-crazy chaos quiets down! LOL…No, I’m not that greedy, really…Seriously. ;~)
Thanks for looking out for my blog!
Comment by danucal — May 18, 2007 #
I just took a bite of my first oreo cookie-cookie!
It was warm, soft, and…buttery?..Well, earth balancey! I didn’t add any cream of tartar, and I baked them for 12 minutes instead of 15. I was suprised that the oreos seemed to meld into the main cookie batter so well because I expected it to taste sort of like 2 different cookies, but it really works, it’s not just a gimmick! :)
i have a semi-sweet chocolate bar that I’ll try using instead of chips next time, for the chunks. I’m also thinking of trying the mint-flavored oreos (heard they’re vegan) for a change of pace. It was very fun to make and easy to boot, thanks celine!
Comment by danucal — May 20, 2007 #
this is wonderful!!! I’m glad you liked. I wish we could bake together, wouldn’t that be fun? :D
Comment by Celine — May 20, 2007 #
Yup, I would love it!;~)
Comment by danucal — May 21, 2007 #
[...] not really “oreo”, but joe-joe. they turned out a bit flatter than the original ones, and I think I figured out why. someone else had the same thing happen to them when they tried the [...]
Pingback by vanilla oreo-cookie cookies « have cake, will travel! — August 17, 2007 #
[...] Oreo Cookie-Cookies. These were sooo good, I might try them without the oreos next time as I think they may then taste just like the chocolate chip cookie of my childhood. [...]
Pingback by love like a vegan — September 18, 2007 #
Hi! I have two questions…is the cream of tartar a must for the recipe? Can I make these with chocolate chips instead of oreo’s?
Comment by Mish — September 20, 2007 #
hey Mish! you can definitely sub chocolate chips for oreos. or you could add pieces of another cookies if the problem is that you can’t find oreos where you’re at.
you could probably replace the cream of tartar with a little more baking powder instead, but I have not tried this and cannot guarantee this will work.
Comment by Celine — September 20, 2007 #
Thanks Celine! I just got my cookies out of the oven and it worked great!!!
My whole apartment smells heavenly, I will gain like 10 pounds tonight, but well worth it!!!
Thanks again for all the recipes you post.
Comment by Mish — September 21, 2007 #
[...] with the recipe: I wanted a slightly healthier, less fatty version of the oreo cookie cookie. despited the “flatitude”, the taste is amazing and I will be adding different things [...]
Pingback by oreo-cookie cookie-based cookie « have cake, will travel! — September 27, 2007 #
[...] not buttery sticks]. my cookies aren’t flat! still unsure as to why it worked with the veganized version of the original recipe the very first several times I made them only to stop a few times later, but [...]
Pingback by Disco Stew and what I hope is the last time I ever mention Oreo Cookie Cookies, for the love of… « have cake, will travel! — September 29, 2007 #
Yay i finally made these and they’re as good as I’d hoped they would be!!! You’re a cookie genius, Celine!
Comment by textual bulldog — October 7, 2007 #
I love your site! I’ve got a vegan potluck coming up and I can’t wait to introduce your oreo cookie-cookies to my group. Do you mind if I copy the recipe as a hand-out with your credits? I’ve got some baking to do….Peace
Comment by hippie vegan chick — October 8, 2007 #
go for it, hippie vegan chick. happy baking time for you!
Comment by Celine — October 8, 2007 #
[...] more oreo cookie cookies [which work perfectly well since I corrected the recipe] [...]
Pingback by my life with cookies « have cake, will travel! — October 9, 2007 #
That’s hilarious! A cookie cookie. Great re-do.
Comment by Deb Schiff — October 10, 2007 #
These are incredible. I’ve been vegan for a year and have been searching for a knock-your-socks-off chocolate chip cookie recipe. thank you thank you thank you!!!!!!!
Comment by Lynn — October 19, 2007 #
I just made these today for a dinner party and they were so delicious and easy! Thanks so much for the new go-to recipe!
Comment by Nora — October 22, 2007 #
glad to hear it pleased, Nora!
Comment by Celine — October 22, 2007 #
[...] Almond Cookies Orange Spritz Cookies Choco Coco Spelt Rice Cookies Savory Lemon Pepper Cookies Oreo Cookie Cookies Chocolate PB Rice Treats Sweet Rice Cookies Rum Spice Cookies Spekuloos Wannabes But Aren’ts [...]
Pingback by Recipe Index « have cake, will travel! — January 30, 2008 #
I made these yesterday and they were terrific and so easy! Really great. (I only used 4 T of sugar and 4 T of brown sugar, but otherwise made exactly as directed - and it was fab!)
Comment by vecca — June 2, 2008 #
must.make.these.
Comment by happyherbivore — June 30, 2008 #